What We Learned About Ometepe Island Nicaragua
I’m going to write a travel book one day. That’s the title:
Don’t Go to That Place, That Place Sucks — in honor of our host in Colombo, Sri Lanka.
What I really mean by that is this: the most over-hyped places you read about and hear about while traveling are often the ones we like the least. Somewhere along the way, I realized we don’t enjoy what the majority of travelers seem to enjoy.
From the moment we arrived in Nicaragua, all we heard were rave reviews about Ometepe Island, sitting off the western edge of Lake Nicaragua. Two volcanoes. Hard hikes. Stunning views. Beyond that, we had no idea what to expect. Naturally, we went to see what all the hype was about.
Splish. Splash. We nearly took a bath in Lake Nicaragua as our ferry behaved more like a bobblehead doll than a boat, battling less-than-ideal wind conditions. I’m sure the two-ton trucks they insist on cramming onboard don’t help much either.
One of the first things that became immediately obvious was how difficult transportation is on the island. There are no real cars—unless you bring one over yourself. You can rent a scooter, which limits you to the “paved” portions of the island, or shell out more money for an ATV (which honestly does sound fun) to tackle the moon-crater roads of the southern end.
After a bit of haggling at our finca (farm) stay, we decided to split a full day of “taxi” transport with two Germans for $90. It seemed like the best way to see the various “highlights” without completely losing our minds.
When I say taxi, I mean the owner’s beat-up Honda that had absolutely seen better decades. Like a Chinese fire drill, we entered through one back door and exited through the other due to unspecified “technical difficulties.” No worries — it’s island time, man. No problem.
Next came the four gringos weighing this thing down. Anytime we approached a hill, it became a collective breath-holding exercise to see if we’d make it. Spoiler: we didn’t. The car required a running start. So out we went—through the back left door only, mind you—walking uphill while waiting for the car to loop around and try again.
These roads were worse than anything back home in Salmon — roads that would make our friends question taking their 4×4 out at all. Holy bleep.
Now, you might be thinking we judged the entire island based on this transportation experience. Nope. We’re travelers. We’re flexible. We’re used to this stuff. What we are judging is the lack of things to actually do. Sure, you can spend nine hours hiking a volcano, but if that’s not your jam, there’s only so much to keep you occupied on what is essentially a floating volcanic hazard.
We did a waterfall hike that turned out to be more of a leaky faucet. The volcanic pool was better, but it involved sitting in lounge chairs surrounded by other tourists — nice, but a pass for us. The one thing that genuinely felt worthwhile was a narrow strip of sand extending into the lake, offering a solid sunset view. Yes, it was touristic, but at least it delivered.
Somehow, people manage to spend days on this island. I genuinely don’t understand how. Maybe relaxing at your B&B is enough. There are no real beaches to hang on, no standout restaurants to write home about. I’m officially stumped.
No worries, though. We were off to an even more hyped destination to finish our holiday the right way — relaxing with a cocktail in San Juan del Sur.




















